Father and son fined €100,000 after horrific farm death

The 71-year-old suffered fatal injuries when he fell through a gap in the roof
Father and son fined €100,000 after horrific farm death

The case was heard at Portlaoise Circuit Court. File image

A FATHER and son have been fined a total of €100,000, after a neighbour fell to his death during construction of an agricultural building on their farm in Laois.

The 71-year-old suffered fatal injuries when he fell through a gap in the roof, landing on a concrete floor below.

Judge Jonathan Dunphy imposed fines of €50,000 each on Seamus McEvoy and Patrick McEvoy at Portlaoise Circuit Court on Thursday 12 November.

The prosecution followed a tragic incident on their farm at Coolderry, Ballacolla, on 9 October 2023, when Michael ‘Mick’ Byrne fell to his death while working on the roof of a new agricultural building.

Mr Byrne’s grieving family had written to the DPP asking that their neighbours, the McEvoys, not be prosecuted over his death.

The Health and Safety Authority (HSA) described the case as ‘a tragic reminder of the devastating consequences that can arise’ when adequate protections are not in place’.

The victim, who had been assisting with the installation of profile metal sheeting to the roof of the building, suffered fatal injuries when he fell through a gap in the roof. He was helping his neighbours to construct a robotic milking parlour and was not an employee.

Both farmers pleaded guilty to Section 15 (3) of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005, in failing to ensure so far as was reasonably practicable that the place of work was safe.

They also pleaded guilty to two other regulations, in failing to appoint a project supervisor for the construction stage of the project and failing to ensure that work at height was properly planned, appropriately supervised and carried out in a manner that was so far as reasonably practicable safe and without risk to health.

Patrick McEvoy also pleaded guilty to failing to ensure that the place of work, at which work at height was or was to be carried out, possessed a surface that had no gap through which an employee could fall.

Following the court sitting, HSA assistant chief executive Eibhlin O’Leary said in a statement: ‘This case is a tragic reminder of the devastating consequences that can arise when adequate protections are not in place.

‘Working at height has the potential to cause serious and fatal injuries. Any work at height must be properly planned and appropriately supervised, with suitable measures in place to prevent falls and protect those carrying out the work.

‘Those who control a place of work have a legal duty to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that it is safe. Where work at height is being undertaken, known risks must be identified and appropriate precautions put in place before work begins.’

Funded by the Court Reporting Scheme 

More in this section