Carlow court judge says defendant’s circumstances ‘bad luck’
Carlow Court House. Photo: Michael O'Rourke
A CARLOW special needs assistant has been fined €500 after being stopped by gardaí for driving without insurance, with a judge describing it as “bad luck” after hearing that his policy had been cancelled over a missed €65 direct debit.
Jake Nolan (28) of Browneshill Wood, Pollerton appeared before Judge Derek Cooney at Carlow District Court, where he pleaded guilty to driving without insurance and to failing to produce a valid insurance policy at a garda station within the ten-day period allowed.
Garda Patrick Ryan told the court that on 1 June at 12.17am, he was on patrol on the Browneshill Road, Carlow, when the Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) device in his patrol car flagged a vehicle in front of him as uninsured.
After stopping the car, Garda Ryan said the defendant told him he believed the vehicle was insured.
The car was seized and Mr Nolan subsequently failed to produce a valid insurance certificate at Carlow Garda Station within the following ten days.
Defence solicitor Chris Hogan told the court that his client thought he was insured and that the misunderstanding arose from a direct debit payment which was missed a month before the stop.
“Jake is of the view that he had three or four different emails and didn’t see it on the date it occurred,” Mr Hogan said.
He handed in a letter from Mr Nolan’s insurance company, dated 2 June, the day after the stop, stating that the direct debit had been missed and that a sum of money was owed.
Judge Cooney said: “His policy was cancelled on 1 May, but he was only notified about this some four weeks later through a letter, one day after the gardaí stopped him.”
Mr Hogan said his client, who works full time as a special needs assistant and has no previous convictions, was anxious to have the matter dealt with that day. He added that Mr Nolan was aware he would receive penalty points and a fine, if convicted.
“Did he not notice that the direct debit didn’t come out of his account?” Judge Cooney asked.
Mr Hogan replied that the amount in question was €65.
“Just as well the gardaí stopped him before anything else happened,” the judge said, before fining Mr Nolan €500, to be paid within six months. He described the case as one of “bad luck”.
“These insurance companies should get on to you straightaway. In this instance, you did not receive any information. I don’t think that is very fair, but I have to apply the law,” Judge Cooney told the defendant.
